2.5 Star Hotel
Simonton Court Historic Inn & Cottages
523 Eaton Street, Key West, FL, United States View Map
1/100


About
Located in Key West, this Florida adult-only inn offers complimentary, light continental breakfast and free Wi-Fi access. Duval Street is 2 minutes’ drive from the property and The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum is 3 minutes’ drive away. A TV, telephone, and a refrigerator are included in all rooms at Key West’s Simonton Court. A balcony or patio is also featured in addition to an private bathroom. The gallery photos show examples of different bedrooms in each category. Guests can enjoy swimming any one of the 4 on-site outdoor pools, use the bicycle hire, or relax in the garden. Kindly note that private parking is available upon request as there are limited spots. Please inform the property in advance. A concierge service and daily maid service are also available. The Southernmost Point of the continental United States of America is 5 minutes’ drive from the inn. Mallory Square is 2 minutes’ drive from the property, and Smathers Beach is 2.6 mi away.
662 Reviews
- Cleanliness
- 9.3
- Staff
- 9.6
- Location
- 9.8
What Guests Say
- “You stepped through the gates and it felt like an exotic tropical escape in the middle of Old Town, very romantic, 4 private pools,…”
- “Location, staff, unique layout, parking”
Room Options
Our Best Price. GUARANTEED.
Exclusively for Priceline members Details
1/1Queen Room
- Air conditioning
- Coffee/tea machine
- Complimentary drinking water
- In-room safe box
1/1Deluxe Bungalow
- Air conditioning
- Coffee/tea machine
- Complimentary drinking water
- In-room safe box
1/2Deluxe King Room
- Air conditioning
- Coffee/tea machine
- Complimentary drinking water
- In-room safe box
1/1King Room
- Air conditioning
- Coffee/tea machine
- Complimentary drinking water
- In-room safe box
1/1Deluxe Queen Room
- Air conditioning
- Coffee/tea machine
- Complimentary drinking water
- In-room safe box
1/2Cottage
- Air conditioning
- Coffee/tea machine
- Complimentary drinking water
- In-room safe box
1/1King Suite with Pool View
- Air conditioning
- Coffee/tea machine
- Complimentary drinking water
- In-room safe box
Have a question?
Ask Penny, powered by AI. Answers are taken from property information and reviews.
What Guests Loved
Based on 662 reviews
Pros +
- You stepped through the gates and it felt like an exotic tropical escape in the middle of Old Town, very romantic, 4 private pools, fantastic breakfast and no kids allowed! The owner (I think she was owner!) was so friendly as was all the staff
- Location, staff, unique layout, parking
- Hotel location was great! The room was just as pictured and described. We did have our blue tooth speaker stolen and wasn't offered anything as compensation. My diamond earring had also be misplaced and the hotel manager (blonde lady) was so very nice.
Cons -
- No, we loved everything about itand I can't say enough good things about it!
- Room layout was odd. They could build out a nice kitchen in the refrigerator room for minimal expense. Bed sunk in the middle.
- When telling staff about missing earring, they offered no help, just like with speaker, manager was close & heard & offered to help she found the earring but hadn't been told about speaker. Which was upsetting
You stepped through the gates and it felt like an exotic tropical escape in the middle of Old Town, very romantic, 4 private pools, fantastic breakfast and no kids allowed! The owner (I think she was owner!) was so friendly as was all the staff
No, we loved everything about itand I can't say enough good things about it!
Location, staff, unique layout, parking
Room layout was odd. They could build out a nice kitchen in the refrigerator room for minimal expense. Bed sunk in the middle.
Hotel location was great! The room was just as pictured and described. We did have our blue tooth speaker stolen and wasn't offered anything as compensation. My diamond earring had also be misplaced and the hotel manager (blonde lady) was so very nice.
When telling staff about missing earring, they offered no help, just like with speaker, manager was close & heard & offered to help she found the earring but hadn't been told about speaker. Which was upsetting
This hotel was perfect! It was exactly what we wanted. It was centrally located. We walked everywhere we wanted to go. The staff was friendly. The grounds were neat. Breakfast was delicious.
We loved it and will stay there again! staff at the front desk was nice and accommodating. The place is gorgeous and we like how there were multiple pools to get in. Central to everything, we couldn¿t ask for a better place to stay in Kew West.
The location, the staff, and. The property itself.
The breakfast selection could have been better.
Nice location, the staff are definitely the star. Room was nice, Our room had a great private balcony SC3 Nice bungalows, Didn't stay in one, but great settings, Nice free breakfast in the morning
The bed was a little soft, The room could have been cleaner.
The hotel was quaint had beautiful grounds wonderful access to every place we wanted to go. I would stay here again.
Our flight changed to a later time but the hotel wouldn't allow us to stay in our room later. That was a little frustrating but other than that it was all good.
Intimate environment Great location
The central air wasnâ≢t the best but the window unit in the bedroom was a lifesaver.
This is a great spot, hotel employee that worked the second shift, made our stay awesome she bent over backwards to make us at home. The only thing I would ask for is a microwave and a larger TV!
Great location. Charming grounds. Very quiet. Great service and cleaning.
The dresser for our room was an antique. This looks great but is clunky to use and the size is not really suitable for two people to use for a one week stay. Also the wooden and laminate surfaces in the room and bathroom are worn. TV was rickety.
The staff was amazing, the hotel is beautiful with a romantic feel, it is conveniently located near everything you need. The complimentary breakfast is delicious and they restock and clean your room daily. What more could you ask for?
Nothing! They exceeded our expectations!
Gardens and pools
Unit facing street, loud cleaning staff in the morning
Garden(s) outstanding. Rooms/cottages outstanding. 1 block off of Duval, very central to all action and/or tours to Hemingway House, Truman's Little White House, Southernmost Point, etc.
No, we loved it all. (Especially Alvin the cat).
Nice grounds. Cozy feel
Parking situation is not convenient and quite expensive per day
The hotel exceeded expectations. Location was great. Ambiance was superb. Staff was friendly and professional. There was a comfort and commraderee with other guests.
Not at all
Best room of the trip. Got a upgrade to Mansion 2 if I remember correctly. Great room with tons of charm and functionality.
Road noise was a bit much, but everything else made up for it.
Great staff, great location, beautiful grounds
No coffee maker in the room, if you have a lower unit you may hear the people above you
Everyone made us feel welcome Very quiet during the evening but close to walki to the noise.
Staff was very courteous and helpful all along the way. Room was pleasant, clean, and quiet.
Amenities & Policies
Amenities
Swimming & Soaking
- Swimming Pool
- Outdoor pool
Media & Technology
- Free Internet Access
Health & Safety
- Health Services
- Daily disinfection
General
- Adult Only
- No Smoking Rooms/Facilities
Guest policies
| Check-in | After 3:00 PM |
|---|---|
| Check-out | Before 11:00 AM |
| Internet | Free Wi-Fi is available. |
| Children & Extra Beds | Children are not allowed. |
| Pets | Pets are not allowed. |
| Room Rates | All rates displayed are for two guests unless otherwise noted. |
Important info
Please note that children cannot be accommodated. Kindly note that parking is available upon request as there are limited spots. Please inform the property in advance.Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
Location
523 Eaton Street, Key West, FL
People also liked
Currently Viewing

Simonton Court Historic Inn & Cottages
Pegasus International Hotel
Key West - Old Town
includes all fees
La Te Da - Adult Only, 21 or older
Key West - Old Town
Restaurant
includes all fees
Hyatt Vacation Club at Sunset Harbor
Key West - Old Town
includes all fees
Ella's Cottages-Key West Historic Inns
Key West - Old Town
includes all fees
Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns
Key West - Old Town
includes all fees
The Mermaid & The Alligator
Key West - Old Town
includes all fees