2.5 Star Hotel

Beachcomber Inn

5909-5911 West Lake Road, Conesus, NY, United States View Map

Beachcomber Inn1/16
Beachcomber Inn photo 2
Beachcomber Inn photo 3
Beachcomber Inn photo 4

Beachcomber Inn

Penny
Hi, I'm Penny! Ask me anything about Beachcomber Inn: rooms, rates, amenities or policies.

About

Beachfront Location Beachcomber Inn in Conesus offers direct beachfront access and stunning lake views. Guests can relax on the sandy shore or enjoy the outdoor seating area. Dining and Entertainment The inn features a family-friendly restaurant serving American cuisine with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. A bar provides a variety of cocktails, while evening entertainment includes live music. Comfortable Accommodations Rooms offer air-conditioning, kitchenettes, private bathrooms, and lake views. Additional amenities include free WiFi, outdoor fireplace, and an outdoor play area. Local Attractions Located 8.1 mi from Suny Geneseo and 31 mi from Greater Rochester International Airport, the inn is near attractions such as Deer Run Winery and Stony Brook State Park.

67 Reviews

8.0Very Good

What Guests Say

  • “The room was spacious, clean and had a great view of the lake!”
  • “We were very pleased with the service and the food in the restaurant.”
Show 50 Verified Reviews

Top Amenities

  • Restaurant
  • Free Internet Access
  • Free Parking
  • Beachfront
  • Non-Smoking Rooms
Show All Amenities

Room Options

Our Best Price. GUARANTEED.

Exclusively for Priceline members Details

Double Room with Lake View1/4

Double Room with Lake View

248 sqft • 1 Queen

  • Air conditioning
  • Alarm clock
  • Bath or Shower
  • Body soap

Room Details and Photos

Room Amenities

    Have a question?

    Ask Penny, powered by AI. Answers are taken from property information and reviews.

    What Guests Loved

    8
    Very Good

    Based on 67 reviews

    Pros +

    • The room was spacious, clean and had a great view of the lake!
    • We were very pleased with the service and the food in the restaurant.
    • The view of the lake from our balcony ? very cozy place. We stayed in the sunrise suite

    Cons -

    • We waited 30 minutes to check in. No attempt was made to make it right. We got an I'm sorry and a bunch of excuses.
    • If you are looking for a luxury hotel this is not it. This is an old school motel with lots of charm.
    • Cleanliness of room. Men's outside bathroom was VERY DIRTY. Appears not detailed cleaned in weeks. Doors,urinal,etc...SMELLY!!
    10DawnPosted on: 5-2-2023

    The room was spacious, clean and had a great view of the lake!

    3DanPosted on: 7-16-2018

    We were very pleased with the service and the food in the restaurant.

    We waited 30 minutes to check in. No attempt was made to make it right. We got an I'm sorry and a bunch of excuses.

    10SprousePosted on: 10-8-2025

    The view of the lake from our balcony ? very cozy place. We stayed in the sunrise suite

    8GrayPosted on: 8-26-2025

    This is an old school motel. We love the charm and the outside bar and Restaurant. They even had music on Friday night and volleyball teams on Thursday

    If you are looking for a luxury hotel this is not it. This is an old school motel with lots of charm.

    5RussellPosted on: 8-22-2025

    People and staff pretty nice.

    Cleanliness of room. Men's outside bathroom was VERY DIRTY. Appears not detailed cleaned in weeks. Doors,urinal,etc...SMELLY!!

    10AmandaPosted on: 6-7-2025

    The room was clean and very cutely decorated. The AC worked well. It’s obvious that the rooms are very well maintained. Beds were very comfortable. It was nice to have the coffee pot and fridge for use. We were really happy with everything and the staff here was wonderful!

    8PatriciaPosted on: 10-14-2024

    No breakfast was included.

    The fact that there was no parking reserved for guests was extremely frustrating. Especially since two restaurants are attached to the motel. In fact, we had to park a good distance down the road and bring our suitcases from that distance.

    10JackPosted on: 10-9-2024

    Beautiful location. Delicious food and local bar. We're able to fish early morning from the dock. Recommend for sure

    9annaPosted on: 9-23-2024

    Perfect location- right on the lake! Room is very comfortable. Bar and restaurant both very nice. Close to Letchworth state park

    9BettePosted on: 8-15-2024

    We LOVED the location, especially the view. Having onsight restaurant/bar is always a plus. It was a great base for our travels and exploration of the region.

    The bed was so high I needed assistance getting in and out but we have found that high beds are the norm in today's hotels. The shower was a bit small but got the job done. A soft chair (all that was provided was 3 dining type chairs) would have been nice but I took the chair from outside our room and put pillows in it to make it comfortable. I realize these things were in mostly due to limitations on my part and would definitely stay here again.

    9JonathanPosted on: 7-28-2024

    Great location - fun place with a good bar and good food.

    Loud music late.

    8REBECCAPosted on: 7-24-2024

    It was a nice place with a cabana bar and great restaurant....room was fine.Staff was awesome

    From the pics of the place I expected to be able to actually sit outside from my room and view the lake.. Could of been my mistake. No creamer for my coffee

    10JessePosted on: 7-17-2024

    Very cozy room and clean. The food at the restaurant was excellent and the live music at the tiki bar was fantastic, would definitely come back.

    9RonPosted on: 10-27-2023

    There is a nice restaurant on the property which was very enjoyable. And a great view of the lake.

    The matress was a little uneven, but still I slept well.

    7SeanPosted on: 10-11-2023

    nice location thou we were out of season

    mattress too old

    5HollyPosted on: 10-1-2023

    The only things I liked was the ability to sit out by the water and the view of the lake from my room. But not worth $135 with tax included $150 a night.

    There was no breakfast or food offered. The restaurant was closed, which they did tell me ahead of time. But for the price of the room there could of at least been some kind of breakfast offered. No mention of how to check in or any signs. I had to call from my vehicle to get a key. There should also be information on the website about the hotel being right next to the main road. If I would have known all this beforehand I probably wouldn't have stayed. Room could of been cleaner as well. A lot of cobwebs and so much dirt and grime under bed and in corners. Could use a good spring cleaning.

    8AimeePosted on: 9-25-2023

    Really enjoyed the atmosphere and Chris the bartender was very welcoming and focused on ensuring guests were well attended to

    Rooms, bed, furniture and decor a little dated for the price of the room

    7JenniferPosted on: 8-31-2023

    The lake front was nice. The bar & grill on property was convenient. We watched some volleyball games while eating dinner. That was enjoyable & relaxing.

    The lightbulb in the only lamp was blown. One recessed light (out of three) was out above the kitchenette. The shower curtain needed to be washed. The mattress was old - definitely had a dip in the center. Replacement would probably be a good decision.

    4AylinPosted on: 8-31-2023

    Location was nice with views of the lake

    Room was musty. Hair in bathroom shower. Sheets were very worn out. They give you a small amount of coffee but no creamer and one coffee filter 10x the size of the coffee machine. Fridge had ring stains. Just overall gross.

    5MatthewPosted on: 7-25-2023

    sheets were clean

    parking issues, whatever they clean with leaves an oily residue on everything that makes it feel dirty, nats around outside eating area are terrible they need to spray for them. Don’t plan on going to bed till the bar closes it is very noisy in the room.

    Amenities & Policies

    Amenities

    Swimming & Soaking

    • Beachfront

    Food & Drinks

    • Restaurant

    Media & Technology

    • Free Internet Access

    Transportation

    • Free Parking

    Health & Safety

    • Health Services
    • Daily disinfection

    General

    • No Smoking Rooms/Facilities

    Guest policies

    Check-inAfter 3:00 PM
    Check-outBefore 11:00 AM
    InternetFree Wi-Fi is available.
    ParkingFree parking is available.
    Children & Extra BedsChildren of all ages are welcome.
    PetsPets are not allowed.
    Room RatesAll rates displayed are for two guests unless otherwise noted.

    Important info

    Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply. Managed by a private host

    Location

    Beachcomber Inn

    5909-5911 West Lake Road, Conesus, NY

    People also liked

    Currently Viewing

    Beachcomber Inn

    Beachcomber Inn

    867 Reviews2.5-Star Hotel

    Back To All Hotels