4-Star Hotel

Baron's Cove

31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY - United States
View Map
Baron's Cove
1/56
  • Overview & Photos
  • Policies
  • Amenities
  • Reviews
  • Rooms
  • Map
$228
per night

4-Star Hotel

Baron's Cove

31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY - United States
View Map

Top Amenities:

BeachfrontFree Internet AccessFree ParkingSwimming PoolFree Airport ShuttleRestaurantFitness CenterSpaBusiness CenterHandicapped Rooms/FacilitiesNo Smoking Rooms/FacilitiesFamily Friendly
Show All Amenities

Guest Rating

8.7

Very Good

Based on 189 reviews

Location Of Hotel

9.5

Hotel Cleanliness

9.3

Hotel Staff

9.2

Overall Quality

8.7

Show 30 Verified Reviews

About

Featuring an on-site restaurant and seasonal saltwater swimming pool, Baron's Cove is located in Sag Harbor, New York. Free WiFi is accessible throughout the property and free private parking is available on site. Each guest room has a flat-screen cable TV and a refrigerator. The private bathrooms include bathrobes and free toiletries. Select rooms offer views of the sea or garden. Guests at Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor are greeted at the 24-hour front desk. Clothing, accessories, and refreshments are available at The Dock Shop. The dining room serves fresh American cuisine and is open daily for lunch and dinner. Breakfast and brunch are available on the weekend. Bike hire is available at this hotel and the area is popular for cycling. Mystic is 30 mi from Baron's Cove, while Montauk is 18 mi away.

Guest Policies

Check-in:

After 16:00

Check-out:

Before 12:00

Pets:

Pets are not allowed.

Important Info:

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply. Our seasonal outdoor swimming pool is open from Memorial Day and closes on the Sunday of Columbus Day Weekend *Weather permitting.

Features & Amenities

Highlighted Amenities:

Beachfront
Free Internet Access
Free Parking
Swimming Pool
Free Airport Shuttle
Restaurant
Fitness Center
Spa
Business Center
Handicapped Rooms/Facilities
No Smoking Rooms/Facilities
Family Friendly

Amenities & Services:

Accessible parking
Aerobics
Beachfront
Business center
Facilities for disabled guests available
Family rooms
Fitness center
Fitness classes
Free Wi-Fi
Free parking
Free shuttle service
Non-smoking property
Outdoor pool
Restaurant (special diets available)
Restaurant(s)
Spa services
Swimming pool
Tennis court & equipment
Yoga classes

Guest Rating

8.7

Very Good

Based on 189 reviews

Location Of Hotel

9.5

Hotel Cleanliness

9.3

Hotel Staff

9.2

Overall Quality

8.7

Pros +

  • Location was good,
  • The attention to small details in service: pool attendants asking to refill my water, free yoga in the morning, housekeeping coming around in the afternoon to see if I needed more towels or water.
  • The hotel was very cute and charming. I would love to come back in the Summer and take advantage of the free bikes and swimming pool

Cons -

  • Restaurant food was inedible topped by sky high prices. Service was slow on all levels; beverages, food. Dinner was not served to all 4 at the same time. Food was salty, portions small, once it arrived. I was not happy with the pillows in the room.
  • I wish breakfast was included with all bookings.
  • Very very poor customer service. Extremely rude and offensive front desk staff. Room was not ready an hour and 20 minutes past check in time and they offered no apology or explanation. They did not even offer us a glass of water, or a seat in the lobby

Business Traveler (7)

Solo Traveler (19)

Traveling as Couple (80)

Family with Young Children (38)

Family with Teens (3)

Senior Traveler (5)

Group Traveler (17)

6
6/3/2022
Location was good,
Restaurant food was inedible topped by sky high prices. Service was slow on all levels; beverages, food. Dinner was not served to all 4 at the same time. Food was salty, portions small, once it arrived. I was not happy with the pillows in the room.
10
5/30/2019
The attention to small details in service: pool attendants asking to refill my water, free yoga in the morning, housekeeping coming around in the afternoon to see if I needed more towels or water.
I wish breakfast was included with all bookings.
9
5/13/2019
The hotel was very cute and charming. I would love to come back in the Summer and take advantage of the free bikes and swimming pool
4
5/1/2019
Cute and trendy hotel with nice rooms walking distance to town
Very very poor customer service. Extremely rude and offensive front desk staff. Room was not ready an hour and 20 minutes past check in time and they offered no apology or explanation. They did not even offer us a glass of water, or a seat in the lobby

Room Options

1/2

Harbor King Room

351 sqft • 1 King and 1 Sofabed

Bath or Shower

Room Details and Photos

1/4

Barons Suite

651 sqft • 1 King • 1 King • 1 Sofabed

Bath or Shower

Room Details and Photos

1/2

Garden Double Room

286 sqft • 2 Double

Bath or Shower

Room Details and Photos

1/4

Village King Room

286 sqft • 1 King

Phone

Room Details and Photos

1/4

Loft Suite

476 sqft • 1 King • 1 Sofabed

Bath or ShowerCrib(s)Refrigerator

Room Details and Photos

1/2

Harbor Two Queen Rooms

351 sqft • 2 Queen

Bath or Shower

Room Details and Photos

Location

Baron's Cove

31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY

Browse destinations

Top Hotel Destinations

Hotels In GrapevineHotels In HoustonHotels In New YorkHotels In AtlantaHotels In WheelingHotels In DallasHotels In CantonHotels In ValenciaHotels In GreensboroHotels In West OrangeHotels In LawrenceHotels In LexingtonHotels In Los AngelesHotels In BismarckHotels In SalemHotels In Blowing RockHotels In MysticHotels In Las VegasHotels In Fort LauderdaleHotels In NorfolkHotels In PortsmouthHotels In National CityHotels In PinevilleHotels In El PasoHotels In MooresvilleHotels In Santa FeHotels In Boulder CityHotels In DavenportHotels In WindsorHotels In Swanton