28 York Place Hotel

Great location and staff.

Room had a smell akin to slight moldiness.

Lovely bedroom and en-suite, clean and comfortable and very close to main attractions.

The shower was a little bit random. It cut out on my husband a couple of times.

Well located and the staff were just brilliant. Room with a view, everything we needed was provided, clean and the bed was massive.

Minor cosmetics in the bathroom.

So pretty hotel as price

I was so scared because the neighbors voices are literally next room, this mean my room has locked door and this door connected to next room. If you are women, be careful

Cosy warm clean and staff are very helpful

Nothing really

Excellent sized rooms, very comfortable. Lovely clean hotel and staff were great.Excellent location within Edinburgh.

We had a wonderful stay! The location is fantastic — close to everything and very convenient. The place was spotless and clearly very well maintained. The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming. The bar has a really cozy atmosphere, perfect for relaxing.We would definitely stay here again and highly recommend it!

Room was comfortable, staff very friendly, location super, good value

It was all good

The bedroom was comfortable and clean

It was difficult to find in the darkness at 6 pm. The road in front of the hotel is a busy thoroughfare with double yellow lines and so we couldn’t stop directly outside. The bar area was closed due to a private party. there is no lift and we were on the second floor. I believe the lift information came after we had made the non-cancellable booking.

Great central location, 5 minute walk to the train station and a perfect base for exploring the city. Reception staff were friendly and helpful. Nice amenities in the room.

Room was extremely small and this could be made clearer when booking, thankfully we were only staying for 1 night but if we were staying any longer it wouldn’t have been comfortable for 2 people. There were a few signs of wear and tear e.g hole in the bathroom door and some of the bulbs in the ceiling lights not working.

Tidy and convenient to city and tram stop. Staff was helpful with bags and room.

It was pricey for the room but likely because of the timing.

Nice and central Massive, comfy bed.

Over £200 for a basic room is way too expensive. No pressure from the shower.

We loved it all!

We chose a room with a view on the 2nd floor. The hotel doesn’t have a lift but luckily I have a strong husband who managed our bags

Location and style of property

Only concert is no elevator for older clients

Fantasic location. Spacious room. Comfy bed

Nothing room was perfect

Room clean, spacious, had all amenities needed. Arran aromatics toiletries in the bathroom were nice.

A beautiful hotel, located in the perfect place for a couple of days in Edinburgh. The staff were fantastic, and the rooms were spacious.

The only fault was some noise from the road and adjoining rooms.

Location,nice comfortable bed ,was clean and nice and quiet .

Lot of stairs to get to our room maybe okay for younger guests .It also had a shower over bath prefer walk in shower .

Location, staff, history, not corporate.

Stayed at 28 york place and of November for the Christmas markets for 1 night. Wish I'd booked longer. It's a hidden gem and value for money. I'd mentioned it was my partners birthday while we were there, they'd put out balloons, birthday card, chocolates and prosecco complementary. Room was beautiful, and great facilities. Staff very friendly will definitely be back again