About
On lush Protestant Cay and accessible only by boat, this Christiansted landmark hotel features a private beach. Free Wi-Fi is available in all areas. A private balcony, a kitchenette and cable TV are found in each bright, decorative room at Hotel on the Cay. Coffee-making facilities and a DVD player are also included. Guests at the Cay Hotel can go snorkeling or enjoy tours by wave runner or kayak. Windsurfing, sailing and paddle boat rentals are also available. An on-site bar and a restaurant are open to all guests at the Cay. Central Christiansted is a 2-minute ferry ride from the hotel. The Buccaneer Golf Club is less than 3 miles away.
Guest Rating
Good
Location Of Hotel
Hotel Cleanliness
Hotel Staff
Overall Quality
Room Options
Superior Ocean View Double Queen
571 sqft • 2 Queen
Room Details and Photos
Two-Bedroom Apartment
1303 sqft • 1 King • 1 King
Room Details and Photos
Family Suite
1045 sqft • 1 King • 1 Single • 1 Sofabed
Room Details and Photos
Superior Ocean View King
571 sqft • 1 King
Room Details and Photos
Guest Rating
Good
Location Of Hotel
Hotel Cleanliness
Hotel Staff
Overall Quality
Pros +
- The location is great. It was clean enough.
- The best thing about this property is the location.
- It was away from everyone
Cons -
- The whole place has seen better days. The floors were sandy.
- The property is under renovation.
- He ocean view but could open patio door cause door broken and hard to open and close
Business Traveler (7)
Solo Traveler (29)
Traveling as Couple (60)
Family with Young Children (52)
Family with Teens (14)
Senior Traveler (26)
Group Traveler (23)
Total (131)
Jennifer
•Posted on: 1-30-2026
The location is great. It was clean enough.
The whole place has seen better days. The floors were sandy.
Kenneth
•Posted on: 1-22-2026
The best thing about this property is the location.
The property is under renovation.
Timothy
•Posted on: 1-21-2026
It was away from everyone
He ocean view but could open patio door cause door broken and hard to open and close
Julie
•Posted on: 1-20-2026
The location
Very run down, unkempt
Top Amenities:
Guest Policies
Check-in:
After 03:00 PM
Check-out:
Before 11:00 AM
Pets:
Pets are not allowed.
Important Info:
You must show a valid photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all special requests cannot be guaranteed and are subject to availability upon check-in. Additional charges may apply.Please inform of your expected arrival time in advance. You can use the Special Requests box when booking, or contact the property directly using the contact details in your confirmation. Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
Features & Amenities
Highlighted Amenities:
Amenities & Services
location
Hotel On The Cay
Po Box 223329, Christiansted, VI
Top Hotel Destinations
- Hotels
- North America
- United States
- Virgin Islands
- Saint Croix
- Hotel On The Cay