Library Hotel by Library Hotel Collection

The location is great and the room with coffee and snacks available to guests is very nice.

It was rundown. The carpets and the wall need attention. The bedding was very clean but the bed and pillows need to be replaced. Also they charged a $25 resort fee at checkout. It was not a resort!

The warm and helpful staff, an intimate feel to the hotel. Lovely bathrooms. The excellent breakfast and evening drinks were particular highlights.

Can't think of a thing.

All the staff was outstanding. They were very courteous, kind, went out of their way to make us feel welcomed. The service was amazing; the 2nd floor library, lounge, business center are very unique. The Library theme is very fitting for our interests.

The ambiance snd location

The staff were amazing. Friendly and helpful.

This is my third time staying here. Loved it hence why I came back. However, this time was not like the past two times. Only room that was available was the smallest with a full size bed. That was ok. But the room was sad. Lightning was horrible. Maybe if it was brighter it may make it better. Couldn't open the blinds on the windows because looking out there was construction and scaffolding. So, the room remained dark and dingy.This is not what I expected from this hotel.

Staff was super friendly and helpful. The hotel has a good quality restaurant on site and a cozy rooftop bar arranged with spaces where you can converse comfortably. These both were handy as we were staying during extreme cold January weather and gave us the option of dining without having to venture out in the cold.

Stay was great, no complaints.

Great location, friendly and helpful staff, clean and elegant spaces

I wish real cream or whole milk would have been supplied in the 2nd floor snack and drink facility. I abhor fake cream packets.Room cleaning was completed a little late, after 4 pm one day, just as I returned from a day of sightseeing and museums and wanted to put my feet up.

Our stay was wonderful. We were upgraded to a king size bedroom, which was wonderful. It was our wedding anniversary. The room had a flower decoration that my wife loved. She wanted to know what the thread count was on the bed sheets because it was so comfortable, but was afraid to ask.

Our only complaint was that we when we asked for directions to the Natural History Museum using the subway the directions we were given were wrong. But that wasn't too big of a deal at all.

I thought both the library and rooftop lounge were extremely nice. And I liked having a restaurant on site. Good location and friendly staff.

My room was freezing and the thermostat not working but a space heater was promptly provided. The room was very small but well done.

The location is terrific! It's an easy walk to and from Broadway theaters. It's convenient to sights, restaurants, and transportation. It's also a charming boutique hotel with excellent common rooms and lounges.

With cold weather, felt the chill near the windows. They could use weather stripping.

LOCATION WAS PERFECT FOR US , FRIENDLY HELPFUL STAFF , VERY COMFORTABLE ROOM AND FACILITIES

NOTHING NOTED

Location, second floor lounge and the rooftop bar

The parking - your partner rips off your guests. Pick a new partner, negotiate the rates after 12 hours or ditch them and find a new one.

Quiet, not pretentious, friendly and welcoming. Staff left us a nice note - we have stayed here 20 years ago and would stay again. Room with complimentary tea and coffee where you can relax.

All was as expected.

Comfortable room, well appointed. The hotel's location is great for any midtown events or museums, tours, etc., plus close to stations and public transport. Appreciated the coffee and drinks in the reading room.

There was a doorman on duty when I arrived midday, but no one was at the door later in the evening or following morning. This absence made the hotel feel less safe, as the elevators do not require a room key to operate. Some of the room furnishings showed signs of wear/age, and for the hotel's price should be updated. Only one elevator was working when I arrived, which meant for long waiting times -- I wound up using the stairs multiple times because it was faster.

The hotel could not be located in a better place , easy access on foot everywhere. The staff were very friendly and helpful and the breakfasts were amazing ! We will be returning to this hotel . The rooftop bar was a great place to unwind .

The scaffolding outside however we learnt this is a must in winter due to the potential snow and its hazards, so fully understandable

Location was excellent for our first time visiting NYC. Hotel not too big

Lifts are a little tired but nothing that is to bothersome

Staff was great. Enjoyed the rooftop bar after the theater. Location is really good, easy walk to Rockefeller Center, etc. Many good restaurants within a mile of the hotel. Good hot water and pressure in shower!

The rooms are small, but after the initial entry, it is fine for what you need. There could be more shelf space in the bathroom and space is available under the one shelf behind the door.

Location

No breakfast service on one day and staff didn’t seem to care

All the staff were so friendly and helpful.The hotel in excellent location.

Everything was very good except that there is no parking in the hotel and the general parking lot is around 10 minutes walking to the hotel, Also the take inconsideration that the size of the normal room is little small

All bedrooms are labelled as a library category. Rooms are quite large with a built in TV and safe. There is no mini bar nor coffee/tea making faciltywithin bedrooms, although there is a 24/7 hour reading room serving refreshments and snacks.

Madison and Vine is a connected restaurant to the hotel which serves good food but is above average pricey. Breakfasts there are pricey as well. better to walk to Central Grand Station and pay for a much cheaper coffee, juice and croissant there.