Pony Island Inn

Location was good. Building old, but maintained. Good size room for a vacation stay.

clean

more places to hang towels would be nice

Everything was great about this hotel. We would come again and recommend it to our friends. ¿¿

No all was good.

Location was great. Staff at check-in and cleaning service was very polite and accommodating. Enjoyed our stay.

Disappointed the restaurant wasn't open during our stay, but we understood why.

Rooms were clean and right next to each other. Love the upgrades, just update the bedspreads and the room will look up to age :)Manager was great.

We went at Christmas so everything was closed. Manager was awesome though.

Great location, helpful and pleasant staff. The room was clean, quiet and nicely decorated.

The only thing I didn't care for was the parking. The parking lot was cramped. Only one way in and out made it difficult to maneuver.

The location is excellent, an equal distance from the beach access and the village. The adjacent restaurant is also good food at great prices. The grill and fish cleaning station were kept clean and orderly. The staff were friendly and amicable with good knowledge of the area.

Perfect restaurant, great location, free air station for those that needed it. Clean, updated, walkable. Will stay here again. Pool looked good too.

Parking lot is a little tight, but it is an Island.

Didn't have breakfast, room was clean and comfortable

Water needs to be hotter

Great location with comfortable two bedroom option. Plenty of parking and large outdoor pool for summer fun. Balcony provides nice view of the sunset.

Breakfast was not available onsite during our November stay.

Everything...location, comfortable beds, dresser in room was very convenient to store clothes instead of routing thru a suitcase all WK, lovely deep full size tub for a lovely soak after a day of exploring the island. Even though it was off season, I loved that the grocer was within walking distance and had a full stock to choose from. I was very pleased w the restaurants that were still opened. Staff was very helpful w info of what was still open and where to go for what. Microwave and fridge n room was perfect Loved the porch and rocking chairsPictures online do not convey the comfort of the room or how well maintained the rooms r. Paint is fresh and bright, floors look new..no carpet is great, bathroom fixtures look new Lost of light where u need it Cleaning staff efficient and friendlyI will stay again ??

Nothing to not like!

Everything.

There were some electrical issues that I made the staff aware of and the information about the wifi was not up to date on the website but also let staff know.

Perfect location and very clean. Staff was helpful and engaging.

Mattresses are getting a little worn out and soft.

It was clean and the guy that checked us in was super nice. Beds were comfy and the room was large.

We had no hot water in our room. We checked out early to catch a ferry. I called later to let them know and the lady at the front desk said yes she knew but never said sorry. It would have been nice but she didn't seem concerned.

It was not a fancy place - but very clean, comfortable, and well maintained.

na

Clean and comfortable. Breakfast restaurant was good.

I could hear through the walls and noisy outdoor guests.

The manager was wonderful and very informative. The only thing that I would like to say is one of the bed mattresses need to be replaced. It’s got a whole types.! we left early so we were not able to inform management

Golf carts were available with the room and added bonus. The Inn was lovely and right in the town. We took the golf cart everywhere. Great breakfast restaurant too!

It was clean, staff was friendly and right off the highway. Front porch was nice to sit on.

The room decode was a little outdated.

Great location, large rooms. Rooms were clean and had all reasonable accommodations.

The beds were super soft and the pillows were uncomfortable.