2-Star Hotel

Open Hearth Lodge

2669 South Bayshore Drive, Sister Bay, WI - United States
View Map
Open Hearth Lodge
1/73
  • Overview & Photos
  • Policies
  • Amenities
  • Reviews
  • Rooms
  • Map
$129
per night

2-Star Hotel

Open Hearth Lodge

2669 South Bayshore Drive, Sister Bay, WI - United States
View Map

Top Amenities:

Free Internet AccessFree ParkingHealth ServicesSwimming PoolFitness CenterSpaPets AllowedHandicapped Rooms/FacilitiesNo Smoking Rooms/FacilitiesHot tub/WhirlpoolFamily Friendly
Show All Amenities

Guest Rating

9.4

Exceptional

Based on 525 reviews

Location Of Hotel

9.5

Hotel Cleanliness

9.6

Hotel Staff

9.8

Overall Quality

9.4

Show 34 Verified Reviews

Featuring an indoor pool and hot tub, Open Hearth Lodge is located in Door County’s Sister Bay. The town center and access to Lake Michigan are 3 minutes’ drive away. Free WiFi access is available. Cable TV is provided in every air-conditioned room at Open Hearth Lodge. There is also a refrigerator and work desk. Featuring a shower, private bathrooms also come with a bath or shower and a hairdryer. Outdoor BBQ facilities and a fire pit are featured at Sister Bay Open Hearth Lodge. Pet friendly rooms are available in select rooms upon request. Other facilities offered at the property include access to hiking and biking trails and a children’s playground. The property offers free parking. Bay Ridge Golf Course is located across the street from this hotel. Peninsula State Park is 10 minutes’ drive away.

Check-in:

After 15:00

Check-out:

Before 11:00

Pets:

Pets are allowed on request. Charges may apply.

Important Info:

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply. In response to the coronavirus (COVID-19), additional safety and sanitation measures are in effect at this property. Food and beverage services at this property may be limited or unavailable due to the coronavirus (COVID-19). Due to the coronavirus (COVID-19), this property is taking steps to protect the safety of guests and staff. Certain services and amenities may be reduced or unavailable as a result. Pet friendly rooms are available in select rooms upon request. The property offers cribs for a fee of USD 5 per stay. Please contact property if arriving after 22:00 for check-in procedure.

Highlighted Amenities:

Free Internet Access
Free Parking
Health Services
Swimming Pool
Fitness Center
Spa
Pets Allowed
Handicapped Rooms/Facilities
No Smoking Rooms/Facilities
Hot tub/Whirlpool
Family Friendly

Amenities & Services:

Accessible parking
Accessible toilet
Daily disinfection
Facilities for disabled guests available
Family rooms
Fitness center
Free Wi-Fi
Free parking
Heated pool
Hot tub/Whirlpool
Indoor pool
Lower bathroom sinks available
Non-smoking property
Non-smoking rooms available
Pets allowed
Spa/sauna
Swimming pool
Swimming pool toys
Wheelchair accessible

Guest Rating

9.4

Exceptional

Based on 525 reviews

Location Of Hotel

9.5

Hotel Cleanliness

9.6

Hotel Staff

9.8

Overall Quality

9.4

Pros +

  • Very clean. Great breakfast. Very nice owner who greeted us. Will definitely stay again.
  • The owner was so personable, greeting us anytime he saw us and made sure we knew all the amenities. He also posted all the happenings in the area including restaurants open and close times. This was incredibly helpful, since it was a holiday weekend.
  • The hotel is staffed by the owner's family. They are super nice and provide excellent entertainment in the breakfast room. This was the best hotel we have stayed at in Door County.

Cons -

  • No
  • Nothing comes to mind
  • No

Business Traveler (12)

Solo Traveler (22)

Traveling as Couple (384)

Family with Young Children (219)

Family with Teens (3)

Senior Traveler (7)

Group Traveler (77)

10
4/26/2025
Very clean. Great breakfast. Very nice owner who greeted us. Will definitely stay again.
No
10
4/24/2025
The owner was so personable, greeting us anytime he saw us and made sure we knew all the amenities. He also posted all the happenings in the area including restaurants open and close times. This was incredibly helpful, since it was a holiday weekend.
10
1/15/2025
The hotel is staffed by the owner's family. They are super nice and provide excellent entertainment in the breakfast room. This was the best hotel we have stayed at in Door County.
7
10/6/2024
very clean every one very friendly

Room Options

1/6

King Room with Spa Bath

380 sqft • 1 Single and 1 Sofabed

Accessible by liftAccessible toiletAir conditioningAlarm clock

Room Details and Photos

1/4

Deluxe King Room

321 sqft • 1 King and 1 Sofabed

Accessible bath/showerAccessible by liftAccessible toiletAir conditioning

Room Details and Photos

1/4

Deluxe King Room

280 sqft • 1 King

Accessible bath/showerAccessible by liftAccessible toiletAir conditioning

Room Details and Photos

1/6

Standard Double Room

286 sqft • 2 Queen

Accessible bath/showerAccessible by liftAccessible toiletAir conditioning

Room Details and Photos

1/6

Superior Queen Room

380 sqft • 2 Queen and 1 Sofabed

Accessible by liftAccessible toiletAir conditioningAlarm clock

Room Details and Photos

1/5

Two-Bedroom Apartment

576 sqft • 1 King • 1 King • 1 Sofabed

Accessible bath/showerAccessible by liftAccessible toiletAir conditioning

Room Details and Photos

Location

Open Hearth Lodge

2669 South Bayshore Drive, Sister Bay, WI