Shelter Island Heights Hotels

Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, New York

There are 44 cheap Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, New York. Choose a hotel below or narrow your search using the filter to the right.

The Bridge Inn - Bridgehampton Image

The Bridge Inn - Bridgehampton

Sag Harbor
Guest Rating: 9.0/10
(1) review
  2 Star
prices from
check rates
Freebies Available
The Hampton Hamlet Inn Image

The Hampton Hamlet Inn

Southampton
Guest Rating: 8.2/10
(12) reviews
  1 Star
prices from
check rates

Themes: Business-Friendly

Freebies Available
The Atlantic Image

The Atlantic

Southampton
Guest Rating: 7.1/10
(11) reviews
  1 Star
prices from
check rates
Freebies Available
Southampton Long Island Hotel Image

Southampton Long Island Hotel

Southampton
Guest Rating: 7.9/10
(13) reviews
  2 Star
prices from
check rates
Freebies Available
East Hampton House Resort Image

East Hampton House Resort

East Hampton
Guest Rating: 9.2/10
(4) reviews
  2 Star
prices from
check rates
Freebies Available
Forever Bungalows Image

Forever Bungalows

East Hampton
Freebies Available
Southampton Inn Image

Southampton Inn

Southampton
Guest Rating: 8.6/10
(16) reviews
  3 Star
prices from
check rates

Themes: Family-Friendly, Business-Friendly

Freebies Available
The Pridwin Hotel Image

The Pridwin Hotel

Shelter Island Heights
Guest Rating: 9.3/10
(3) reviews
  3 Star
prices from
check rates
Freebies Available
Baron's Cove Image

Baron's Cove

Sag Harbor
Guest Rating: 9.3/10
(3) reviews
  4 Star
prices from
check rates
Freebies Available
SEVEN - Shelter Island, a boutique bed and breakfast Image
Freebies Available

We also have 37 more hotels in nearby areas:
Hamptons Brazil Guest House Image

Hamptons Brazil Guest House

East Hampton
Guest Rating: 10.0/10
(2) reviews
Freebies Available
Topping Rose House Image

Topping Rose House

Sag Harbor
  5 Star
prices from
check rates
Freebies Available
c/o The Maidstone Image

c/o The Maidstone

East Hampton
Guest Rating: 10.0/10
(1) review
  3 Star
prices from
check rates
Freebies Available
The Hedges Inn Image

The Hedges Inn

East Hampton
  3 and 1/2 Star
prices from
check rates
Freebies Available

44 Shelter Island Heights Hotels
Narrow your search to:

dg

Priceline.com is part of The Priceline Group, the world leader in online travel & related services.